ARGUMENTATIVE TEXT (LKPD 2026)
The Existential Threat: Why We Must Regulate
AI Now
|
Thesis |
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has rapidly
evolved from a futuristic concept into an integral part of our daily lives.
From recommendation algorithms to autonomous vehicles, its benefits are
undeniable. However, the unchecked acceleration of AI development poses
severe risks to humanity. It is crucial that governments and tech companies
implement strict regulations immediately, as the dangers of job displacement
and mass disinformation are no longer theoretical, but imminent. |
|
Argument 1 |
It can
lead to job displacement. First, the widespread adoption of AI threatens to
disrupt the global workforce on an unprecedented scale. Unlike previous
industrial revolutions that replaced physical labor, AI competes with human
intellect. According to a 2023 report by Goldman Sachs, generative AI could
potentially automate activities equivalent to 300 million full-time jobs
globally. This shift does not only affect low-skilled labor but also impacts
creative and administrative professions. Without a safety net or clear
regulation, this could lead to economic instability and widening inequality. |
|
Argument 2 |
Furthermore,
it takes into account disinformation & democracy. AI possesses the
dangerous capacity to amplify disinformation, threatening the fabric of
democracy. Generative AI tools can create "deepfakes" (realistic
but fake images and videos) and generate misleading text at a massive scale. The
World Economic Forum’s "Global Risks Report 2024" ranks AI-derived
misinformation and disinformation as the top global risk for the next two
years. If bad actors use these tools to manipulate elections or incite
violence, the societal consequences could be catastrophic. |
|
Argument 3 |
Finally,
it is lack of accountability. There is the issue of the "black box" problem, where even
developers do not fully understand how their AI models arrive at certain
decisions. This lack of transparency leads to algorithmic bias and
discrimination in critical areas like hiring, law enforcement, and lending.
Without strict legal frameworks, there is no accountability when an AI system
causes harm to individuals. |
|
Conclusion/Reiteration |
In
conclusion, while AI offers transformative potential, its dangers—economic
disruption, the collapse of truth, and lack of accountability—are too
significant to ignore. Innovation must not come at the cost of human
security. Therefore, immediate and robust global regulation is not just an
option; it is a necessity to ensure AI serves humanity rather than destroys
it. |
LIST OF VOCABULARIES
|
No |
Vocabularies |
Meaning
|
|
1 |
|
|
|
2 |
|
|
|
3 |
|
|
|
4 |
|
|
|
Next |
|
|
LKPD
HAPPY
"The
AI Policy Makers"
Karakteristik: Mampu berpikir abstrak, kosakata
luas, mandiri.
Pendekatan
STEAM: Engineering
(Logika Struktur) & Mathematics (Proyeksi Data).
Activity
1: Deconstructing Arguments (Mencapai TP 2)
Instruksi: Bertindaklah sebagai insinyur
data. Bongkar struktur teks argumentasi penulis dan evaluasi kekuatan buktinya.
|
Paragraph Focus |
Main Idea (Ide
Pokok) |
Supporting
Evidence (Detail Pendukung) |
Validity Check
(Math/Science) |
|
Thesis |
Write the thesis
in your own words. |
- |
- |
|
Argument 1
(Economy) |
... |
... |
Is the "300
million" figure a fact or prediction? Explain based on the modal verbs
used. |
|
Argument 2
(Democracy) |
... |
... |
How does
"Deepfake" technology logically lead to "collapse of
truth"? Connect the cause-effect. |
Activity
2: The Implicit Analysis (Mencapai TP 1)
Instruksi: Jawab pertanyaan berikut untuk
menggali makna tersirat.
- Tone
Analysis: The
author uses the phrase "unchecked acceleration" instead
of just "fast growth". What does this imply about the
author's attitude towards Tech CEOs?
- Future
Projection (Math/Science):
Based on the text, if regulation is not implemented immediately,
what is the implicit consequence for the year 2030 mentioned or hinted at
in the text?
JOYFUL
"The
Fact Checkers"
Karakteristik: Mampu memahami teks dengan bantuan
visual, butuh panduan struktur.
Pendekatan
STEAM: Art
(Visualisasi) & Technology (Identifikasi Isu).
Activity
1: Information Sorting (Mencapai TP 1)
Instruksi: Berikut adalah daftar informasi
dari teks. Tentukan apakah informasi tersebut Explicit (Tertulis jelas)
atau Implicit (Kesimpulan/Makna tersembunyi). Beri tanda centang (✔).
|
Statement
from/based on Text |
Explicit
(Tersurat) |
Implicit
(Tersirat) |
Evidence/Reason |
|
"AI could
automate 300 million full-time jobs." |
... |
... |
Because it is
written directly with numbers. |
|
"The writer is
worried/afraid of the future." |
... |
... |
Not written, but
felt through words like 'threat' and 'danger'. |
|
"Governments are
currently too slow in making rules." |
... |
... |
Inferred from the
call to act "immediately". |
|
"Deepfakes can
create misleading text." |
... |
... |
... |
Activity
2: Mind Mapping the Details (Mencapai TP 2)
Instruksi
(Art/Engineering):
Lengkapi Peta Pikiran (Mind Map) di bawah ini untuk menghubungkan Ide Pokok
dengan Detail Pendukungnya.
- CENTER: The Dangers of AI
- BRANCH
1 (Main Idea):
Economic Threat
- Detail
(Data):
_________ (Cari angka di teks)
- Detail
(Source):
_________ (Cari nama Bank di teks)
- BRANCH
2 (Main Idea):
Political Threat
- Detail
(Tech):
_________ (Cari istilah teknologi palsu)
- Detail
(Source):
_________ (Cari nama Laporan Global)
GLAD
"The
Data Explorers"
Karakteristik: Butuh scaffolding (bantuan
bertahap), fokus pada kosakata kunci dan informasi konkret.
Pendekatan
STEAM: Mathematics
(Pencarian Angka) & Visual (Gambar).
Activity
1: Hunting for Facts (Mencapai TP 1 - Tersurat)
Instruksi
(Math/Science):
Scan teks (baca cepat) untuk menemukan data (angka/fakta) berikut. Tulis
kalimat lengkapnya.
- Find
the Number:
Berapa jumlah pekerjaan yang terancam?
- Answer: ____________________ jobs.
- Find
the Source:
Siapa yang mengeluarkan "Global Risks Report"?
- Answer: The World
____________________ Forum.
- Find
the Object:
Apa nama teknologi yang bisa membuat video palsu?
- Answer: Deep_____________ .
Activity
2: Matching Ideas (Mencapai TP 2)
Instruksi: Tarik garis (Engineering/Logic)
untuk menghubungkan Ide Pokok di sebelah kiri dengan Detail Pendukung yang
sesuai di sebelah kanan.
|
MAIN IDEA (Ide
Pokok) |
SUPPORTING DETAIL
(Detail Pendukung) |
|
|
1. AI threatens jobs
(Economy) |
↔ |
A. Deepfakes and
misinformation can manipulate elections. |
|
2. AI threatens truth
(Democracy) |
↔ |
B. Developers do not
understand how AI makes decisions ("Black Box"). |
|
3. Lack of
Accountability |
↔ |
C. Goldman Sachs
report says 300 million jobs could be lost. |
.png)
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar